Mind Reading
Moshe Ben-Chaim
Mesora: A renowned rabbi recently described the Besht with mind reading capabilities. If Moses could not mind read, certainly the Besht could not. We read on Yom Kippur, "God alone knows the thoughts of every man". This Rabbi's proliferation of fallacy misleads those unaware. It is imperative that man understand that only God possesses such a capacity. Deifying man is against Torah. Mindreading offers no insight into God's creation, therefore it does not exist. God created only that which furthers man's understanding of Himself. One must not to be swayed by anyone's reputation, even if he is called a rabbi. Moses made mistakes. His brother Aaron questioned him, and Moses admitted his error (Lev. 10:17-20) Certainly rabbis today err. Unfortunately, the error was in the area of God's unique ability to discern man's thoughts.
Reader: I offer you kudos for your efforts and your well thought out responses to certain issues. But I must argue against your stance about the person who spoke of the Baal Shem Tov's ability to "read minds" as false. People "read minds" all the time-- figuratively; and "know" what a person is about to say very often. Haven't you faced a person and stared deeply into his eyes, caught the flutter of an eye lid, a rapid twitch of the cheek, and knew he was inclined to say this or that?
It's much akin to reading a book. Some people are better book-readers than others because they know the signals certain writers send out, because they're well read in that area of literature, etc. And some people "read minds" better than others, too.
Now, to be sure, only G-d Almighty knows minds from the inside out. But plenty of people read them. That's all the man was saying, it seems to me.
Mesora: Your response is not Talmudic, and lacks any proof. This is not how the Tanaaim or Rishonim would answer. They would base concepts on rational proofs, and/or evidence,.....but not mere projections as is the case of your assumptions.
You may feel that mind reading is at work in this scenario, but it is very easily explained: You are witnessing facial "twitches" which are identical to those which you experience yourself. What you call mind reading can be easily explained as follows: You witness others duplicating your own facial behavior. Since their behavior seems identical yours, their subsequent response is expected by you. This response is what you would have said, as they have similar facial expressions followed by similar responses. This behavioral pattern allows you to second guess their words before they roll off their lips. As you would have said the same following such facial expressions, you interpret this as mind reading, when in reality it is mere projection.
The wisest of men, King Solomon, had to ask the two harlots for their respective alibis prior to rendering his decision. Why didn't the wisest man use mind reading? The answer is that the Torah does not endorse this. Additionally, King Solomon received great praise from the people precisely for the opposite of what you suppose. He received praise for the wisdom employed in determining who was guilty and who was innocent. This is what the Torah praises, not the capacity you assume man possesses, to simply read a mind, which really would require no wisdom.
Again, we read in the prayers for the high holidays, that G-d alone knows man's thoughts. The words of the Anshei Knesset Hagadola deny man's ability to read minds.
The rabbis' words attest that man does not have this ability. Had he, all chaos would break loose.
This is why I believe G-d did not impart this knowledge to man.

Philosophy | Tnach | New Postings | JewishTimes | Audio Archives | Suggested Reading | Live Classes | Search | Letters | Q&A's | Community Action | Volunteer | Links | Education | Chat | Banners | Classifieds | Advertise | Donate | Donors | About Us | Press | Contacts | Home


Mesora website designed by NYDesign.com
© 2003 Mesora of New York, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Articles may be reprinted without permission.